Here’s a bold statement: The Dallas Cowboys’ season finale against the New York Giants isn’t just another game—it’s a test of resilience, strategy, and legacy. But here’s where it gets controversial: While the Cowboys aim to extend their nine-game winning streak against the Giants, whispers of tanking for a better draft position linger in the air for both teams. Could this be a game where losing is more beneficial than winning? Let’s dive in.
The Cowboys head to East Rutherford on Sunday, wrapping up their 2025 season with a familiar foe. Flashback to Week 2, when Dallas and New York delivered a heart-stopping 40-37 overtime thriller at AT&T Stadium. Both teams combined for 41 points in the fourth quarter alone—a testament to their offensive firepower. This time, Dallas hopes to replicate that offensive magic while tightening up a defense that’s been, well, less than stellar lately.
And this is the part most people miss: The Cowboys’ dominance over the Giants isn’t just a fluke. They’ve won the last nine matchups, the longest active streak in the NFL. Dak Prescott, meanwhile, has an astonishing 14-0 record against New York as a starter—the second-best streak in NFL history. But can they make it 10 straight? And will Prescott secure his 15th consecutive win against the Giants?
Our team weighs in with their predictions, and the opinions are as varied as they are passionate.
Patrik isn’t exactly brimming with confidence. He points out the Cowboys’ defensive struggles, highlighted by their recent Christmas Day scare against Josh Johnson and the Commanders. While Dak Prescott’s history against the Giants is undeniable, Patrik questions the offense’s tendency to start hot and fizzle out in the second half. His prediction? A 35-27 Cowboys win, but don’t expect it to be pretty.
Tommy takes a more optimistic approach. He acknowledges the Giants’ transformation since Week 2, particularly with rookie QB Jaxson Dart’s dual-threat capabilities. Tommy believes the Cowboys’ defense will need to step up significantly, especially against Dart’s mobility. If Dallas can dominate the line of scrimmage, protect Prescott, and establish a run game, he sees them closing the season on a high note: 24-20, Cowboys.
Nick highlights the unique dilemma of this game: Is winning really the best outcome? With draft positioning at stake—the Giants currently hold the No. 2 spot, while the Cowboys are at No. 14—a loss could be more valuable. However, Dak Prescott’s planned appearance suggests Dallas is playing to win. Nick predicts a low-scoring affair due to weather, with the Cowboys eking out a 24-16 victory.
Mickey is skeptical, noting the Cowboys’ decision to rest injured players and the Giants’ potential motivation to lose for a better draft pick. With significant roster changes for both teams since Week 2—including the Giants’ firing of head coach Brian Daboll and the loss of key players like Malik Nabers and Kayvon Thibodeaux—this game feels unpredictable. Mickey sees a close contest, with the Cowboys squeaking out a 23-20 win, possibly with Dak Prescott handing the reins to Joe Milton mid-game.
Now, here’s the controversial question: Should either team really be playing to win this game? Or is tanking for a higher draft pick the smarter move? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—this debate is far from settled.
